Rouse Lawyers

- The Law Firm For Business Owners and Entrepreneurs -

Call us: (07) 3648 9900

  • Home
  • Expertise
    • Corporate & Commercial
    • Private Wealth & Tax
    • Franchising
    • Technology
    • Intellectual Property
    • Commercial Litigation
    • Employment Law
    • Estate Planning
    • Property Law
  • About
    • Our Team
  • Reviews
  • Articles
  • Careers
  • Legal Guide
  • Contact

“No Refunds” Clauses Unfair

UPCOMING CHANGES TO

Businesses must take care to ensure that standard form contracts, such as terms and conditions or terms of trade, are not considered ‘unfair’ pursuant to the Australian Consumer Law (ACL).

The case of Ferme v Kimberley Discovery Cruises Pty Ltd involved a cruise ship operator and a category 4 tropical cyclone.

Shortly before the cruise was to depart, the cyclone struck and the operator was forced to cancel. It then attempted to enforce the following term in its standard form contract to avoid refunding the affected passengers:

The carrier will endeavour to follow the Cruise itinerary as described in the brochure and the passenger accepts that the carrier has the right to vary the itinerary or cancel the Cruise if the carrier considers that this is necessary as a result of some Unexpected Event or prevailing inclement weather conditions and the passenger accepts that the passenger will not be entitled to any compensation or a refund of the dare paid should this occur except as provided for in these terms and conditions.

Fortunately for the passengers, they were able to claim for the cancellation under their travel insurance. The insurers then exercised their right to recover against the cruise ship operator and brought an action on the passengers’ behalf.

The insurers argued that the clause refusing the refund was unfair, and relied upon the ACL. The ACL provides that a term in a standard form consumer contract is unfair if:

  1. it would cause a significant imbalance in the parties’ rights and obligations arising under a contract;
  2. it is not reasonably necessary in order to protect the legitimate interests of the party who would be advantaged by the term; and
  3. it would cause detriment (whether financial or otherwise) to a party if it were to be applied or relied on.

The insurer was successful in its claim against the cruise operator, establishing that there was a standard form consumer contract and the terms were unfair.

Takeaway

This case highlights the need to take particular care in preparing standard form contracts. This is especially important where amounts paid under a contract are to be forfeited before the contract, or a substantial part of it, is performed. In these cases, a business must be able to prove that the forfeiture is justified.

It also emphasises the need for consumers to scrutinise the fine print of standard form contracts, and to be aware of their rights under the ACL.


Contact the team at Rouse Lawyers to discuss your legal needs today.

August 23, 2017 Filed Under: Commercial Litigation, Corporate & Commercial

Enter your details below to contact a professional Commercial Litigation lawyer.

↓

We add new contacts to Rouse Lawyers database. We may send you information or service offerings we believe may be relevant to you. If you agree to being contacted by us in the future, send your enquiry. Naturally, you can unsubscribe any time.

Client Reviews

"I would highly recommend Ben and the Rouse Lawyers team"

We are expanding our growing business into new areas. Ben Thorn took the time to understand our needs and delivered timely and expert advice. In addition to his coverage of the commercial transactions, Ben guided us through each step of the process of registering our trade mark. I would highly recommend Ben and the Rouse Lawyers team.

Jon MailerProtrade United

"Smooth, affordable and manageable"

“We recently engaged Rouse Lawyers to assist us in purchasing our first home. The support we received from Jesse Mason and his team was invaluable, easing the overwhelming emotions of being first time homebuyers. He supported us to understand both the land and home contracts, walking us through the process and promptly responding to any concerns, which made the whole process smooth, affordable and manageable”.

Nick JohnstonHitachi Construction Machinery (Australia) Pty Ltd

“We highly recommend Rouse Lawyers”

“Camfil Farr is a multinational organisation and we use lawyers across the world. Rouse Lawyers, was chosen as alternative to the top tier, and have acted for us in a number of matters concerning our Australian operations. We have found their strategic advice and alternate approaches to the law to be highly valuable and unique. We highly recommend Rouse Lawyers”

Bruce LandfordCamfil Farr

PRIVACY POLICY DISCLAIMER TERMS

BRISBANE OFFICE

Ph: +61 7 3648 9900

Fx: +61 7 3648 9911

Level 2, 22 Wandoo St, Fortitude Valley, QLD 4006

17-Page Guide Reveals:

How To Protect Your Business and Your Assets While Allowing Your Business To Thrive

Written by Matthew Rouse, commercial lawyer and founder of Rouse Lawyers.

17-Page Guide Reveals:

How To Protect Your Business and Your Assets While Allowing Your Business To Thrive

Written by Matthew Rouse, commercial lawyer and founder of Rouse Lawyers.

Sign Up To Our Newsletter